Italy 2012 Guidebook
Best and worst restaurants:
Best: Restaurants in Salerno (not in book as this town gets very short treatment in RS Italy)
Why: Al Cenacolo for upscale Campanian food near cathedral, or Ristorante Pizzeria Pinocchio on seafront. For the latter, look behind name and big neon sign of the namesake cartoon character; it is a very good restaurant with excellent seafood and other Campanian dishes. All Salerno restaurants we encountered were very reasonably priced.
Worst: recommended pizzerias in Naples -- Da Michele and that other one across the street
Why: I'm sure the pizza is great -- but we'll never know! A sea of people outside trying to get in, at about 3 pm on a Friday. So I thought, WWRD? (what would Rick do?). Undoubtedly, wade into the crowd, charm it with some broken Italian, and soon be seated at the best table as the locals performed an impromptu folk dance. But we, being made of lesser stuff, simply had a gelato next door and saved our appetite for another good dinner back in Salerno.
Phil in Washington, DC USA 12/20/2011
Best: Ristorante il Gabriello (Rome)
Why: It was so good we ate there at both the beginning and end of our trip. The food was superb, the service was excellent (with the exception of one haughty young waitress on our second visit), and the restaurant is lovely. The panna cotta with caramel sauce is wonderful - we had it on both visits. It is expensive but the splurge was worth it.
Worst: None
Why: All of the recommended restaurants at which we ate were very good.
Karen in Winnipeg, MB Canada 11/27/2011
Best: Dao Lilo restaurant in Reiomaggiore, IT
Why: Recommended by both the Guidebook, and Massimo (of the Canolli Brothers in Vernazza), this place lived up to its reputation for dinner.
Worst: Il Pirun, Corniglia, IT
Why: The recommended Il Pirum, in Corniglia was not as it was described. Since the (also recommended) restaurant next door was packed, we tried Il Pirun. Mario, the proprietor, was not at all welcoming, but since it was lunch hour and we were hungry after the high trail hike from Vernazza, we decided to stay. The restaurant, up a narrow curving staircase, was nice enough, but completely empty. The teenage waitress was very surly and played an Italian version of MTV very loud on a wide screen TV. We asked for separate checks, and were greeted with disgust. Then we learned that we would be charged 2.5 euros per person as a cover charge. The food was good enough, but too expensive considering the cover charge, and I certainly cannot recommend the atmosphere or service!
Arlene Geist in Seattle, WA USA 11/08/2011
Best: Dar Poeta_Rome and Galottis for gelata
Why: Best pizza in 3 weeks touring Italy. The desert Nutella calzone was pure heaven. Went back when we had 24hour delay because of Air France strike and we got a bonus night in Rome-VERY GOOD LUCK!!!
Jolanda Terhoeven in Pretoria, SOUTH AFRICA 11/07/2011
Best: Antica Osteria Da Divo, Siena
Why: Incredible setting - multiple levels carved into the rock. Creative and fresh cooking. Lots of fresh truffles. Great service and a good wine list.
Worst: Trattoria Mario's, Florence
Why: Tourist overload - this must be in every guidebook worldwide. Cramped seating. Food isn't bad but also not great. At least it was cheap.
John Osgood in New York, NY USA 11/01/2011
Best: Osteria del Conte in Montepulciano,
Why: Delicious food, wonderful wait staff, and a true Italian dining experience capped off when the owner visits your table to see if you are satisfied. Don't miss this experience but reservations are needed as it is small and the people don't eat and run.
Pat in Middletown, DE USA 10/31/2011
Best: Pirates in Vernazza
Why: Incredible food, the owners are very entertaining. we ate there 3 times.
Dale Kingsbury in St. Paul, mn USA 10/28/2011
Best: Pirates in Vernazza
Why: Incredible food, the owners are very entertaining. we ate there 3 times.
Dale Kingsbury in St. Paul, mn USA 10/28/2011
Best: Miky's - Monterosso, Cinque Terre
Why: Anchovy sampler platter was fantastic. Right on the waterfront, friendly service.
Mark and Doreen in Pittsburgh, PA USA 10/21/2011
Worst: Ristorante La Pentolaccia in Rome
Why: Food was good but service was awful. It was Sunday evening and I don't know if they were short on help but our waiter just seemed to ignore us. Courses came very slow. Very disappointed given the price of the meal
Nancy in Scotch Plains, NJ USA 10/06/2011
Best: Ristorante La Loggetta in Cortona
Why: The Food was absolutely amazing
Laura Lee Crosetti in Putnam, CT USA 09/30/2011
Best: Ristorante Belforte, Vernazza, Cinque terre
Why: Owner/Manager very engaging guy. Waiter was friendly, hard-working. View was unbeatable, lovely breeze. Food was excellent--the only really good restaurant we found in our entire trip. Be prepared to spend the egg money but it is worth it.
Worst: No real "worst."
Why: We found most restaurants in Rome and Florence only satisfactory at best. Some were less so. Very ordinary, often mediocre food.
Dick and Denise Devlin in Kingston, NH USA 09/26/2011
Best: La Palomba in Orvieto
Why: Homemade pasta with shaved truffles. YUM
Barbara James in Beaufort , SC USA 09/25/2011
Best: Restaurante Miky
Why: Reservations are a must as Miky fills up fast. It opens at 7pm - and there was a line at the door at 7pm. Fortunately I had made a reservation as those without one werer being turned away.
We had probably the best dinner we have had in a long time. It started with splitting the spaghetti with clams ‘Primi’. It arrived in a crock covered with a thin, crispy dough shell that gets flambéed with brandy. It gets torn off and is like pizza crust that the spaghetti gets put on. Delicious, with fresh tomatoes and lots of little clams in the shell - we are still talking about it.
Then the main event - Presentation of my mixed grilled seafood was incredible. Fresh tuna with capers, swordfish, scampi, prawns, razor clams, calamari and scallops - all laid out on a huge square plate. It was pretty to look at and tasted even better. My husband had a huge steak smothered in balsamic with cherry tomatoes and chipolini onions. It was truly OUTSTANDING! With a bottle of the house wine it was about €121 (about $165) with tip and worth every penny.
Laurie in Martinez, CA USA 09/24/2011
Best: So many!
Why: In Varenna: Vecchia Varenna, Ristorante la Vista, Ristorante del Sole (great pizza and we sat in the garden) In Bellagio: La Punta Ristorante (so peaceful and we needed the escape from the busy town) In Monterosso: Il Casello, Ristorante Belvedere, In Florence: Grom (we went there twice in the same day) Borgo Antico- Panzanella Salad and Pizza- so good, Trattoria Marione (osso bucco)
Worst: None!
Why: Everything we tried was great- we were in Florence 3 days 2 nights August 24th, 25th and 26th and a lot of the restaurants in your book were closed (we expected that and want to go back another time to try them!)
Liza in Syracuse, NY USA 09/05/2011
Best: Couldn't get in to most of your recommendations
Why: Best food we found in Italy was in Pisa and Bologna
Worst: Die Frescobaldi restaurant in Florence
Why: Terrible food and rude staff
Pat Geddes in Berthoud, CO USA 08/16/2011
Best: Target
Why: Best pizza I have ever had!
Angel in Katy, TX USA 07/27/2011
Best: Ristorante il Gabriello in Rome
Why: The food was incredible and the atmosphere was delightful. Claudio and his support team enjoy what they are doing. The dining in many of these restaurants was like a celebration with friends...which of course is what it was.
Joe and Lila Klein in Richmond, MN USA 07/26/2011
Best: La Rinascente Food court in Milan; La Lampara in S. Margharita; Restaurant Metastasio; Tre Pupazzi
Why: While the Restaurant Metastasio in Assisi had the greatest view on our trip, the food was superb and should not be underestimated. Also, Tre Pupazzi in Rome along Borgo Pio has incredible food and a great menu and very reasonable.
Worst: Trattoria Milanese in Milan
Why: We could not find it.
John and Elyse O'Kane in Stone Mountain, GA USA 07/24/2011
Best: All of them
Why: All recommendations were great!
Debbie in Benton, Ky USA 07/20/2011
Best: RISTORO DI CAMBI in Florence
Why: Absolutely the best beef I've eaten in my life. To die for. Great service! They allowed us to dine without a reservation, but we arrived relatively early at 7PM. Reservations would be a good idea. Waitress was very pleasant and patient with my daughter and her three new summer-session-abroad roommates who joined us for dinner. Fresh caprese salad was a treat and the local pasta dishes were delightful. House white wine was very nice. Great value too. I'd go back to Italy just for the beef!
Maureen in Grayslake, IL USA 07/18/2011
Best: Ristorante Pizzeria Sacro e Profano
Why: This was really hard to find near the Trevi fountain. The streets were not marked (or at least we never found any signs). One family arrived with the Rick Steve's book in hand and said they had reservations from the night before but could never find it. The food was different. Never had Calabrian food before, but it was a nice change.
Worst: Ricci Est Est Est Pizzeria
Why: We went there twice because we liked the food. But the first time we went our receipt was stamped with "Service not included" so we tipped. The next time we went, our receipt was not stamped. So we felt gouged.
D Mitchell in Elk Grove, CA USA 07/12/2011
Best: ROME: BY THE SPANISH STEPS
Why: I DO NOT KNOW THE NAME OF THE RESTAURANT...SORRY
SANDI KELLY in SARASOTA, FL USA 07/10/2011
Best: ROME: Ristorante alla Rampa
Why: Located in a small square near the Spanish Steps, this restaurant is excellent. It used to be recommended by RS, but was dropped from the books several years ago, which we can't understand. We have been there several times over the years, and always enjoyed it. It has the most incredible antipasto bar, and we routinely make a meal of that alone. House wine is very reasonably priced, and outdoor seating is excellent. It should be included once again as a recommendation.
Ron in DeWitt, MI USA 06/30/2011
Best: Venice: Antica Berraria la Corte
Why: Exactly as recommended by RS, we ate dinner there two of our three nights in Venice. Food and service were excellent; lots of outdoor seating; and the big square which our young grandkids loved. They played with other children from the restaurant and the neighborhood as we older folks finished our wine and relaxed. A great spot.
Ron in DeWitt, MI USA 06/30/2011
Best: Marina Piccola and Trattoria Dal Billy in Manarola
Why: The first is on the water; the second has a great view of the water. Great food and service at both restaurants.
Worst: Osteria da Mario
Why: We were sitting outside; the restaurant adjoins a bar, and someone seated at the table abutting ours was blowing smoke our way, so we asked to be moved indoors (before we'd disturbed the table setting.) Our waiter was very annoyed about moving us, and our service suffered because of it. The owner actually told our waiter to bring us our check before we asked for it.
Lynette Taylor in Brooksville, FL USA 06/24/2011
Best: Trattoria da Billy
Why: Service by Eduardo, Aria di Mare's Maurizio's brother, was devoted, humorous, and welcoming of female couples. Plus, the food was superb and the sunset view of the ocean was gorgeous.
Roxanne in Seattle, WA USA 06/20/2011
Best: Vecchia Varenna
Why: The lake fish dishes were absolutely delicious, as were the desserts.
Worst: none
Why: All of the restaurants recommended were excellent. We stayed away from the menu turistico because we wanted the real thing.
Liz Santos in Seattle, WA USA 06/06/2011
Best: Trattoria la Pallota in Assisi
Why: Great service, unusual food, lovely setting. I left my camera, hat and scarf there, and they called the hotel to tell me, and I picked it up the next day. Stefano at La Pallota was also very generous about helping us.
suzanne conrad in Trinity Center, CA USA 05/31/2011
Best: Taverna Le Coppelle in Rome
Why: Outstanding pizza, good wine, fast service, lively atmosphere, low prices. What's not to like?
Worst: Osteria al Duca in Verona
Why: The food served here is WAY beyond the comfort range of most RS travelers, I'm pretty sure. Lots of horse and donkey meat, and some of the other local dishes are really hard to like (thin slices of cold veal with a tuna/mayo spread on it that was disgusting).
Michael in Seattle, WA USA 05/25/2011
Best: Antica Osteria Il Baretto
Why: Even thought there is not a sea view, you can sit outside and people watch. The food was delicious and more reasonably priceded then the restaurants on the square.
Worst: Trattoria Gianni
Why: Loved the hotel, but the food was not that great and very expensive. There vino del la casa was per bottle. Could not get a carafe. Was expensive and again, not the good.
Penney Haas in Belleville, IL USA 05/17/2011
Best: La Palomba
Why: very good quality and price
Worst: Agriturismo Pomonte, Umbria
Why: The food and wine was mediocre and we (4 of us) didn't eat almost anything and we were charged an exhobirant price (35 euros per head for nothing)
Elizabeth George in CLES, TN Italy 05/15/2011
Best: Lucca / Osteria via S. Giorgio
Why: All four of our dishes were outstanding. It was by far our favorite restaurant in Italy.
S. Blank in Seattle, WA USA 05/06/2011
Best: Ristorante Antica Sacrestia
Why: Only had Pizza Diavola and house wine, but was very good, despite being jammed. Would definitely visit again and recommend.
Worst: Ristorante alla Conchiglia
Why: Had the advertised fixed-price dinner. Where do I start? Paper napkins (everyone else in view had cloth). Stale bread. No butter. Wife had lasagne w/ meat sauce, breaded chicken cutlet and green salad. Lasagne "sauce" looked and tasted as if made w/ Campbell's Tomato Soup...no "meat" to be found. Breaded chicken breast was paper thin, and only of reasonable size due to being pounded to size. Worst was the green salad, which was yellow and almost the core. On the other hand, I had the spaghetti w/ clam sauce, fish fillet and roasted potatoes, which other than being treated like second class customers, was good. Don't waste your time or money.
Marshall Bender in Seattle, WA USA 04/28/2011
Best: Trattoria del Moro Aronne in Orvieto
Why: Best pasta ever, anywhere!
rachele in napa, ca USA 04/19/2011
Best: Trattoria del Moro, Orvieto, Italy
Why: The Nidi was to die for......as was the canneloni. Perhaps the best meal of our 9 day journey.
Jona Matevish in Santa Rosa, CA USA 03/14/2011
Best: Sorrento....il Buco and L'antica Trattoria a close 2nd
Why: fabulous food at both and servers at il Buco made it one of the best meals ever ...both expensive but worth every euro....
Pete Hall in Haddonfield, NJ USA 02/20/2011
Best: L'Alta Marea
Why: Amazing seafood. Best in Italy
Worst: Trattoria da Erminio
Why: Worst steak we we have ever had. The meat was rancid and tasted and smelled bad. We sent it back but were charged for it anyway.
Marisol Grossling in Vancouver, BC Canada 01/04/2011
Worst: trattoria pizzeria al Nono Risorto, venice
Why: the pizza tastes like cardboard, the house wine was bad, and they charged me a 2 euro cover charge on top of the excessively expensive bad pizza and bad wine
candace crawford in new orleans, la USA 01/04/2011
Best: Pizza House, Rome just blocks from Vatican
Why: They had the best food at reasonable prices. They offered wonderfully prepared meats & vegetables. Don't let the name fool you. It's more than just pizza. It is a local, mostly take out restaurant with only 6 or 8 stools to dine in. It is run by Daniele Luciani who has been running it since1950. His daughter & son also help. The son speaks English. Daniele does not. The cost for meats & vegetable ran about 7 or 8 Euros. They are located at Via delle Fornaci 85 in Rome. Well worth the walk if you want good food at a great price & don't care about atmosphere.
Worst: Villa Rita Restaurant, Paestum
Why: Note that the Hotel Villa Rita was great. Just the restaurant was bad. The food was terrible. The price about 15 Euros not including drink, was not bad. But the food was terrible. I had salmon and the cut was one we use for canned salmon. IT was not good, even after picking through the bones. Nothing was good. We ate what we could just because we were too tired to go back out & find something else. Service was good but didn't come close to making up for the poor food quality.
Barbara in Tampa, Fl USA 12/04/2010
Best: Fortunato, Roma
Why: Excellent value for quality experience (best price on white truffles), no attitude, honored reservation in the face of heated demand. Nice wine rec, without trying to sell us the most expensive bottles.
Peter McAndrews in Santa Monica , CA USA 11/29/2010
Best: Osteria da Alberto, Venice
Why: All-around good food, and my son's gnocchi with quattro/cinque formaggi were heavenly - light gnocchi, tangy sauce.
Worst: trattoria da Emilia, Sorrento
Why: (see above.) Nothing we were served was above average, and my gnocchi were not good at all -- hard, cold, and insipid. The place was a zoo when we got there, so they just dumped the plates and utensils at the end of the table for us to distribute amongst ourselves.
Diana Oertel in San Francisco, CA USA 11/12/2010
Best: Golden View, Florence
Why: Food is awesome, location os great and the view is "golden":)
Garnet Holden in Grass Valley, CA USA 11/11/2010
Best: Amalfi Coast: Amalfi: Da Maria--just beyond the Duomo on same side of street; San Giuseppe, off same street but up alley and steps to the left (follow sign on wall; in Atrani--Le Palme--facing the beach under the road; in Positano--Le Tri Sorella on the beach.
Why: Good food, reasonable prices, service and nice atmosphere at all. In Atrani, Le Palme was one of few restaurants open due to a mudslide through the main piazza a month ago but it was great!
martin in HOPEWELL, VA USA 11/03/2010
Best: Il Perata delle Cinque Terre
Why: We had by far our best and most creative dinner here on our 4th and last night in Vernazza. We also ate breakfast at this restaurant every morning. The coffee was delicious and the pastries were fantastic and unique.
Worst: Trattoria del Capitano
Why: This restaurant was a rip off and by far the most expensive with the poorest quality food. The book is wrong about this place serving the best food for the money. They clearing are ripping off the tourists since the restaurant was listed in this book. Finding a good place to eat (good food, reasonable price) between the Vernazza train station and the harbor was a tricky business. The book gave an accurate assessment of Trattoria Gianni (old reliable standby).
Jim Gray in Novato, CA USA 10/24/2010
Best: La Vecchie Mura Ristorante
Why: Dinner under the Tuscan Moon!Please call ahead for a good table, this is a must don't miss it, you really want the patio in summer.
John O Neill in Encinitas, Ca USA 10/17/2010
Best: Trattoria da Erminio in Assisi
Why: Amazing food.
John MacBain in Carmel, IN USA 10/17/2010
Best: Miky's in Monterosso, Italy (Cinque Terre)
Why: The service was fun and attentive and the food was delicious! No one had a bad bite. Of all the things you recommended in Cinque Terre, you hit the head on this recommendation.
Kate in Ostfildren-Nellingen, DE 10/13/2010
Worst: Cantina Paradiso, Rome-Trastevere
Why: BEWARE of this place. At lunchtime, menu says buffet, as mentioned in the book. Unfriendly waitress says no buffet. Then I see blackboard on wall with menu del giorno for 12 euros. I ask if is this available and am told Yes. I order it for my wife and myself. Instead of a 24 euro bill for lunch it is 65 euros, because they charge everything ala carte.
Allan Singer in Torrance, Ca USA 10/10/2010
Best: Antica Osteria Da Divo, Sienna
Why: Atmosphere great, in a cave! Very romantic. Delicious innovative food in interesting sauces.
Jill Ellis in Del Mar, CA USA 10/04/2010
Best: Sacre - Rome
Why: Their pizza was the best we had in Italy. The "creamed sausage" was delicious! Finally had the heat kick we were craving! They now charge a 15% service fee, however, and are not open everyday.
Andrea Kidd in Highlands Ranch, CO USA 09/28/2010
Best: Miky's, in Monterosso, in Cinque Terre
Why: We decided to do a full-course meal at one restaurant during our trip, and this was an excellent choice! The staff was friendly, and the food was amazing!
Heather Cole in Cambridge, MA USA 09/28/2010
Best: Delfino's, Sorrento
Why: Great fresh seafood (we watched the fisherman catching tomorrow's fish while we ate), fun and friendly staff and the great view across the Bay of Naples to Mt Vesuvius. da Giovanni in Rome is a close second.
Steve Madsen in Newcastle, Australia 09/26/2010
Best: Il Pirata della Cinque Terra, Vernazza
Why: Best service! The twins are amazing! The fresh pastries, best in northern Italy. Plus, I left my camera in my room. They responded to my e-mail, found it and then mailed it back and refused any reward or even shipping compensation!
Worst: Franco's Ristorante La Torre, Vernazza
Why: Red Alert: This place does have a view but your glowing review is way off base! The actual floor tilts badly (as did our table on the far right as you enter). The service was almost non-existant (we had to keep getting up to fing our waiter after waiting ten minutes each time). The food was unappetizing and way over-priced. We gave up waiting for our bill (and, as we paid it, without letting on our disappointment, the family, I guess, provided small dessert treat, which I take to mean that the intent to please didn't pass through their waiters to their customers).
Peter Hebard in Albuquerque, NM USA 09/10/2010
Best: Ristorante Guidoriccio, in Siena
Why: My wife, friends and I want to thank you for your recommendation of Guidoriccio’s Ristaurante in Sienna, Italy. We had mistakenly tried to cram far too much into one day and embarked on a blisteringly fast tour of Sienna. At the midpoint of the tour, our tour guide turned us loose for lunch in the middle of town with the admonition to be back in one hour. Fast food places abounded, but luckily I had my Rick Steves book in hand that recommended Guidoriccio’s Ristourante right around the corner. Our friends were apprehensive about being able to eat a fine meal and make our one hour deadline (note the first photo – their facial expressions say it all - wish I could post photos here). Ercole, our host, did you proud. He more than lived up to all of the fine things you mentioned in your book. He noted your book, observed that your words were a high honor and a constant reminder that they had to be lived up to. When we told him of our time constraint, he said that while it was unfortunate that our time constraint would not allow us to fully appreciate all that he had to offer, it was now his responsibility to ensure that we enjoyed a fine meal within our time limitations. Needless to say, the meal was superb, we enjoyed it immensely (note the second photo) and we were able to continue the rest of the tour of Sienna. We had many fine meals while in Italy. Ercole made this one special.
Mike Higgins in Vandalia, Oh USA 09/06/2010
Worst: Il Porticciolo Manarola
Why: It was recommended in the Rick Steve's Guide book which is why we went. We went after the vineyard walk which was great. However, we had the worst meal of our trip at this restaurant. We waited in line for an hour. We were cut in line with full knowledge of the staff. We were finally sat at the table. The waiter apologized for the delay and only started to ask for our order after half an hour. Our meal was an hour later. so we sat watching the chef from our table - they have a door that lets you peak into the kitchen. you don't get that much of a view but its nice. The staff at one point all came in they closed the door and than opened it again. We didn't think anything of it. However, we noticed the chef plating pasta from a pan into two dishes. we didn't think anything of it. Until we got our pasta. It was clear that the pasta porticciolo that we were served was a half portion. It could be the staff was talking about how to deal with the massive amounts of clientele that night and this one way to do it. The other tables next to us ordered the same dish. It came 15 minutes later but it was twice the size of ours. They forgot our secondi order until we reminded them of it. It could be our experience was a one-off for the restaurant. It was not clear why we were getting mistreated. There were other tourists there. Another family next to ours were clearly having a great time at the restaurant - they also came because of the book. The waiter was clearly a lot more attentive to that family. We would not recommend this restaurant. It was not good value and we left hungry. We had such limited time in cinque terre and we were really looking forward to it. We were terribly disappointed in this experience.
Christina in New York, USA 09/05/2010
Best: Page 603: restaurant Osteria al Giardino.
Why: Excellent service, and great food at reasonable prices. Outdoor dining in a small (5-7 table) leaf-covered trellis, is very enjoyable. Huge wine list - some are over 150 Euros a bottle - but wine-by-glass available, and OK.
Worst: Page 603: restaurant Trattoria l'Angelo
Why: Owner very off-hand. Meal was below average quality, and not cheap.
Steve in Pleasanton, CA USA 08/08/2010
Best: Gianni Franzi ( Vernazza), Belforte ( Vernazza), La Vecchia Mura (San Gimignano) ,Trattoria del Moro Aronne (Orvieto)
Why: Gianni Franzi - Wonderful decor, great local white wines, fresh fish and fabulous pesto trofie pasta!
Belforte- Interesting and beautiful cliffside views, excellent seafood dishes with lots of flavor and fresh produce.
La Vecchia Mura - Spectacular views of the Tuscan countryside from the patio!!! Probably the most beautiful dining spot on the trip. Great wine and hearty meals with a Tuscan flair. Great desserts.
Trattoria Del Moro Aronne - Mouth watering Nidi pasta dish, good wine in a family style intimate setting. Definitely worth stopping in for this Umbrian delight.
Worst: Ristorante Oniga ( Venice)
Why: Great location, good atmosphere but be sure to order a prima piatti for the portions are small ( very small) and will leave you hungry for more. Thank goodness Grom ( the gelato shop) was right next door.
Diann Danska in Benicia, CA USA 08/04/2010
Best: Dar Poeta in Rome
Why: Absolutely incredible pizza. By far the best we had in Italy.
Andy Traisman in Eugene, OR USA 07/31/2010
Best: every gelato shop and foccacia in the cinque terre
Why: it was my diet for the entire trip
andrew in tiburon, ca USA 07/28/2010
Best: all of the restaurants that we went to that were suggested by Rick Steves were wonderful.
Why: I actually don't think you can go wrong with food in Italy. But all of Rick's suggestions that we tried were perfect;good service, great food, charming atmosphere.
I would definitely recommend the Hostaria del Ponte right before the bridge going into Civita di Bagnoregio. The view is something you'd see in a magazine and the food and service is tremendous too.
Debbie Kotas in Evergreen, CO USA 07/21/2010
Best: Trattoria del Moro Aronne in Orvieto
Why: Lovely dinner
Worst: La Gallina Bianca in Rome
Why: Too expensive
Joan Goddard in Boulder, CO USA 07/18/2010
Best: Risotrante Belforte's and Ristorante Ripa del Sole
Why: Ahhhh! I had such a fantastic time exploring the five towna and eating their wonderful food. In Riomaggiore, I ate at Ristorante Ripa del Sole and ADORED it! I had their trophie pasta with lesto sauce and almost licked the plate. I also had a glass of their house red wine while wathcing the sun set from my seat. In Vernazza, I ate at Ristorante Belforte and fell in love with the ocean view, sweet white house wine (given to me compliemntary for some reason), and trofie al pesto. WOW that was incredible! The waiters and waitresses were really nice and some kitchen dude came out and started feeding a seagull infront of me little fishies (I was literally right on the water overlooking another fabulous sunset)! sooo cool! Most of all, i loved the locals in the Riomaggiore restaurant and the mix of locals and foreigners at the Vernazza restaurant.
Amanda Kwon in St. Louis, MO USA 07/13/2010
Best: La Cambusa, Positano
Why: Great fresh seafood, wonderful view, good service.
Eric Johnson in Acworth, GA USA 07/10/2010
Best: Restorante Pizzeria "da Francesco" in Rome.
Why: Delicious food at a reasonable price, and great place for meeting people. Close to Piazza Navona.
Worst: Ristorante de Fagioli
Why: Snubbed by the waiter. Probably not a common occurrence, but we requested vegetarian dishes.
Sherry Houpt in Dallas, TX USA 07/03/2010
Best: Il Chianti in Rome, Ricchi Cafe in Florence, Boutique Gelato in Venice
Why: Good food, good prices
Hung Nguyen in Santa Clara, CA USA 06/26/2010
Best: Trattoria ZaZa in Florence
Why: Excellent food even though the service was impersonal--the wait staff seemed to be spread thinly--don't know whether that is the norm for this establishment.
Worst: canal-side, fixed price restaurant in Venice
Why: I deviated from the fixed price menue and ordered scampi out of curiosity--my entree consisted of 10-12 tiny (popcorn shrimp-sized) scampi--very tasty but not filling and a bit pricey at 24 euros! I went back to the hotel and filled up on Pringles!
Michalene Perry in Punta Gorda, FL USA 06/24/2010
Best: Verona - Al Pomperie
Why: Best Meal of our two week trip! Every bite had our eyes rolling to the back of our head. The atmosphere and service are really special with lots of attention - 'Papa' came to our table to tell us about their special selection of hams. A nice young man helped us make our selection for the cheese course - served with yummy chutneys and relishes. You could tell this was a true locals favorite by the lack of English speaking diners in the room (though we had no trouble ordering). We were glad we had a reservation as we watched several apparent locals being turned away at the door.
Terry in Wilmington, DE USA 06/19/2010
Best: La Boutique del Gelato - Venice (pg. 129)
Why: You were spot on about finding the gelateria in Venice and mentioning its generous portions. Each scoop was extremely big (the largest we had in Italy) and quite tasty. On the other hand, the helpings at Gran Caffe Lavena at St. Mark's Square (also on page 129) seemed very stingy in comparison.
Carol Jin in Glen Cove, NY USA 06/10/2010
Best: Il Cavatappi
Why: So intimate with only 5 tables, warm & friendly, interesting chef/owner (very intense!), excellent food & wine served efficiently by our young, smiling waitress.
Barbara Jennings in Munds Park, AZ USA 06/10/2010
Best:
Why: I took a photograph of a photo of Rick Steves at La Scogliera taverna in Manarola. They have it posted right my their menu board on the street. Too bad I can't attach a photo???
Jan Loveland in Key West, FL USA 06/07/2010
Best: Ristorante Enoteca Corsi
Why: The food was great and Giuliana made it special. And we topped our lunch off with the family homemade limoncello. I would highly recommend it, a fun place to have lunch.
Diane Triolo in Gilbert, Az USA 06/06/2010
Best: Trattoria da Olinda in Trastevere area
Why: It really was like eating at someone's home. We were the only Americans our hight at 8 pm when they open. It was about to sprinle rain so we ate inside near kitchen door which was great fun to see and hear the staff inact just like it would be at home. The taste of the food had another deepth of value we haven't had anywhere else in Rome. We split an antipasti, a pasta plate and dessert and we each had a 1/2 carafe of house red/white and expresso and total was 20 euro each with an American sized tip (couldn't help ourselves since we were splitting the plates). When we were done we could stick our heads in kitchen to say thank you for a great meal to the older woman who was clearly the owner. Many locals came ate while we were there. What a great experience.
Worst: Finding it down the little lanes of the Trastevere area
Why: It wasn't really the worst and we would have been able to do it without Rick Steves' guide. We knew he would not have put it in the book unless we could find it so off we went to find it. We did find it but the sign said "Osteria da Olindo" instead of "Trattoria da Olinda" but it was the same address - maybe they change the sign since Rick was there. Since we got there a half hour before they opnned we did practice walking back to the Ponte Sisto so after wine with dinner and darkness we could get home again. But really it was still light and you're never far from the river and people will gladly help in the Trastevere area!! See there us no worst!
Mary-London Eldred in Bremerton, WA USA 06/01/2010
Best: Enoteca Can Grande (Verona)
Why: I had read 2 of Rick's blogs on this restaurant and was staying 4 days in Verona the week after Rick was there. We ordered mixed antipasti from the owner as Rick recommended and was not disapponted. The owner noted that Rick had just been there. We drank wine and finished with pasta. It was so good that we returned 2 days later and did it all over again. If you want personal attention from the owners of a small restaurant and excellent food, you should try Enoteca Can Grande. RicK was right!!
Jim Perschbacher in Atlanta, GA USA 05/29/2010
Best: Trattoria la Burrasca
Why: The food, ambiance, and personal attention by the waiter and chef made this a most memorable dining experience. We abandoned the grotesque food offered by our tour and waited on the steps of the Mercado Central for this place to open one evening. We were the first customers in the restaurant and watched the place fill quickly. The relaxed, friendly atmosphere was a welcome change from the bustle outside and we were quickly revived after our Florentine adventures. Rick's description was 100% accurate much to our delight. Beware that the guidbook lists the restaurant as being on the north corner of the Mercado Central but we almost missed it because it is actually one or two buildings in from the corner. To not experience such exceptional dining would have been a tragedy!
Lisa Donegan in Baltimore, MD USA 05/28/2010
Best: Trattoria la Burrasca
Why: The food, ambiance, and personal attention by the waiter and chef made this a most memorable dining experience. We abandoned the grotesque food offered by our tour and waited on the steps of the Mercado Central for this place to open one evening. We were the first customers in the restaurant and watched the place fill quickly. The relaxed, friendly atmosphere was a welcome change from the bustle outside and we were quickly revived after our Florentine adventures. Rick's description was 100% accurate much to our delight. Beware that the guidbook lists the restaurant as being on the north corner of the Mercado Central but we almost missed it because it is actually one or two buildings in from the corner. To not experience such exceptional dining would have been a tragedy!
Lisa Donegan in Baltimore, MD USA 05/28/2010
Best: Via Venti - Monterossa & La Lampara - Riomaggiore
Why: VIA VENTI - Well worth finding this place off the main street. The service and food were wonderful. We are still craving the homemade ravioli with seafood sauce. LaLampara - The seafood spaghetti in foil was the best. We loved Chario the elderly gentleman working at the restaurant. Great service.
Susie Deyo in LaConner, WA USA 05/22/2010
Best: Trattoria Il Porticciolo - Manarola;
Why: Great Service and Great food. I would even mention the La Scogliera restaurant in your book, as we had a wonderful dinner there. The calamari, Spaghetti Seafood and Octopus Spaghetti were outstanding. If you like spicy sauce the Octopus Spaghetti was wonderful.
Susie Deyo in LaConner, WA USA 05/22/2010
Best: Hotel Olivedo
Why: We did not buy into the 1/2 pension meal and room arrangement because we generally like to explore on our own in a place. So we ate there by choice after our discussion re the fixed menu (25 euro for 4 courses). We have never gone back to the same restaurant twice in a row as we like to explore new places each night. Well we threw that out the window 10 seconds into our meal at Hotel Olivedo dining room. We ate there both nights in Varenna and were blown away both times. The service was prompt and attentive and the food was spectacular. Thanks to Laura's menu I now have an addiction to pumpkin gnocchi (Thanks for sharing the recipe Laura!) The fresh lake trout, veal, and lamb eaten at our table were awesome. the soup, gnocchi, ravioli and desserts were wonderful. Thanks for putting this in the guidebook Rick! Places like this will keep me buying the book!
Brenda MacAlpine in Prince William, NB Canada 05/16/2010
Best: Ristorante A Lampara - Santa Margherita
Why: The true Italian restaurant experience. Tried the seafood ravioli recommended in the book - and they were fantastic. Spent a few minutes talking with the mother (waitress) and son (chef) after our lunch - delightful people and a great place.
Mark Antonioli in Alamo, CA USA 05/15/2010
Best: Osteria Nonna Gina
Why: The food was outstanding the service was patient and helpfull; great prices; good ambiance
Worst: Ai Quattro Feri in Venice
Why: Without asking sat another couple at our very small table; we were rushed in making a selection; provided very limited assistance; appeared annoyed that we were not quick enough and asking too many questions; I would not recommend this restaurant; to be fair the food was good
Ken Gedgaudas in Hollywood, CA USA 05/09/2010
Best: Trattoria del Capitano
Why: Excellent food and service, fair prices
Chuck Bradshaw in Franklin, VA USA 05/02/2010
Best: Ristorante Enoteca Corsi in Rome
Why: As you suggested, we felt like family, especially when Claudia saw your book and brought out the family-made limoncello! Traditional, straight forward, excellent cuisine in a friendly atmosphere, off the tourist path. (Psst, let's not tell anyone. This place is our cherished secret.) We loved it, even after two weeks seaking out the best restaurants in Tuscanny, Florence and Rome.
Karen Matheson in West Simsbury, CT USA 05/01/2010
Best:
Why: we got our best recommendations from the tour guides.
Dennis Phelan in Portland, OR USA 04/25/2010
Best: Vernazza - in the fort above the sea
Why: Good atmosphere, views, and the anchovies were out of this world!
Brian in Fort Wayne, IN USA 04/12/2010
Best: Hostaria Romana, Rome
Why: Great food, a fun atmosphere. However, reservations should be made. This is a favorite among the locals. With tables close together, it is fun to have conversations with other visitors to Rome or with the locals.
Anne Duda in Rocklin, CA USA 04/10/2010
Best: Il Fratellini, Firenze
Why: Quick, good, as advertised
Worst: Rosticceria San Bartolomeo, Venice
Why: Rubbery seafood. To be fair, it was Easter Sunday. Still, I expect better in Italy.
Greg Barnes in Seattle, WA USA 04/08/2010
Best: La Boutique del Gelato
Why: Best tasting gelato for the best value, exactly described in Rick's book. I found it to be better than any of the other recommended gelato places in both Florence and Rome.
Grace in Seattle, USA 03/21/2010
Best: Ristorante A Lampara, S. Margh. Lig.
Why: Local, typical Ligurian food, good prices, nice people.
Elaine in Livingston, MT USA 03/19/2010
Best: Trebbio in Florence
Why: It was good food. But cover fee was a bit high.
Worst: San Marione & Trattoria Mario
Why: Main entrees were not good.
Scott Yu in Mountain View, CA USA 01/01/2010
Best: 2 bests in Florence--Frescobaldi and Ristorante Paoli
Why: Food at both was the best we had in Italy so far. Thanks for recommending them.
John W. Long in Buckeye, AZ USA 12/01/2009
Best: See below
Why: Rome: 1. Ristorante il Gabriello - great food, good service (way too many RS books out though!). Hidden a bit - hard to find. 2. Ristorante Pentolaccia - Kind of a brief mention in the book, but everthing was very well prepared and the host very gracious/friendly. Sorrento: L'Antica Tratoria - Very good food, a bit pricey.
Worst: See Below
Why: Rome: 1. Da Giovanni - Not bad, good value, but service was really slow/disinterested. Sorrento: 1. Delfino - Not bad, just not as good as the top. Service was a bit disinterested at first but warmed up to friendly after a bit (not sure if having the book out made a difference). Food was fine, but a bit unremarkable.
Lloyd in Mill Creek, WA USA 11/29/2009
Best: Alla Stregga - Venice
Why: Pizzas were terrific - we ate pizza all through Tuscany (we drove extensively through out the area), Rome and Venice and we thought they were the best. Nice place and pleasant garden area.
Worst: Porticciolo in Manarola, Cinque Terre
Why: Service was very poor; while they welcomed you into the restaurant very quickly - once we were seated they were not so helpful. When my husband indicated his meal was not good (mine was excellent) the wait staff became quite rude. They certainly stressed the "Rick Steves" recommendation when we went into the restaurant. We wouldn't go there again.
Rita Dahlie in Vancouver, BC Canada 11/25/2009
Best: SAMARCANDA MILAN/MALPENSA AIRPORT
Why: Rick had no recommended restaurant in the Milan/ Malpensa Airport area so we freelanced. Was the best meal we had in our 9 days in Italy! Recommended by our Holiday Inn Express, in Somma Lombardo, a short walk from the hotel. (You can see the runways from the village.) Food, wine, atmosphere were terrific, reasonable, and a great way to spend our final night in Italy.
CINDY in BEAVERCREEK, OH USA 11/19/2009
Best: Memorable
Why: Venice - al Ponte del Meggio, Galle Larga very local Florence - Trattoria la Burrasca, cozy spoke with chef over a cheese plate he put together for us. Cafe on the corner of vis Nazionale and Faenzia Cinque Terra - Vernazza Antica Osteria 11 Baretto ask to sit in teh samll front room where locals are. Luch was so good we returned for dinner. Of course Il Pirata delle make reservations fro night and go by 7pm or still plan to wait Rome Pizza La Gallina Bianca, Ristorante alla Rampa buffet lunch prior to Vatican and yes Mc Donalds for Ice Tea by republica fountain at the end of a long day.
Tom & Laura in Denville, NJ USA 11/18/2009
Best: Osteria da Alberto
Why: Excellent food and attentive service. Fortunately, we did not need a reservation.
Worst: Trattoria Za Za and an unnamed restaraunt by the Rialto Bridge
Why: We left because the waitress would not provide an Italian menu. It appeared to obviously cater to the American tourist. The place at the Rialto Bridge, other than the ambiance of sitting by the canal, had very fast service, so-so food, and excessively high prices. The waiter even pushed for a tip after adding 15% service charge. We generally found our best food when we had to struggle with half English and half Italian.
Richard Raub in Portland, OR USA 11/17/2009
Best: Cas Nobilii, Venice and the one in San Barnabas Square
Why: Not sure of spelling as can't find my book. Liked the above restaurants, food well prepared, good wine on menu and nice wait staff.
Worst: Chat qui rit in Venice, Italy
Why: This was a self serve near San Marco Square. It was crowded and when I tried to go past the cashier to see if there were any vacant tables, he came from behind the till and started (literally) screaming at me. I told him what I was doing and he said I could not go back there at all -a waiter would find a table AFTER we got in line and bought food. We got in line, no prices on anything but we got a simple lunch including one small salade mista for which we had usually paid about 4 or 5 euros in other restaurants. I estimated our cost would be about 20 euros total. My husband reached for a glass, it slipped off the shelf and broke the edge of his salad plate so he took another salad and put the broken plate up on the top shelf beside the cashier. The cashier requested 39.50 euros. I told him something was wrong -it was way too much. He demanded payment, I said that then we did not want it. He said, "You took it off the shelf, you pay me or I call the police (all in a loud screaming voice). We paid to avoid embarrassment and I examined the bill later and found we were charged 16 euros for 2 salad mistas. It was quieter then so I went back to the cashier and I asked him to explain. He said we had to pay for the salad we broke plus the replacement. I said that was fine but a small salad is only 4 or 5 euros -and at this point, he said "You broke a plate and a glass" and I charge you for them. So I guess he charged 8 euros for the cheap plate and glass but he had tried to cover it up by putting it on the bill as salad. I don't think this place should be recommended due to the very rude behaviour of the cashier and also because the persons behind the counter keep pushing food at you, it has no prices on it and they act very offended if you don't take everything they are pushing.
Mary Bruce in Surrey, BC Canada 11/16/2009
Best: La Carbonara
Why: Our first night in Rome, I used by RS phrase book to make a reservation earlier in the day. The food was wonderful. Service a little cool, but efficient. Great meal.
Susan Beach in Forest Park, IL USA 11/16/2009
Best: Taverna Garibaldi
Why: Reasonable price, good pizza, friendly owner and waitress
Irv and Deb Espedal in Deforest, WI USA 11/15/2009
Worst: L'Antica trattoria-Sorrento
Why: Highly overpriced! I realize that it was listed as a splurge but we were underwhelmed!!! With so many choices of good food ( including many restaurants not listed in the guide). This is definitely NOT worth the price.
Nancy Antin in Minneapolis, MN USA 11/14/2009
Best: La Grotta (Cortona)
Why: Exceptional food and service. Definitely make reservations. The pasta is fantastic but if you need break from it try the grilled chicken.
Susan Cramer in Lynnwood, WA USA 11/04/2009
Best: Il Pirata- Florence
Why: Delicious food, good variety to choose from, great price and in the evening we were serenaded with guitar playing and singing.
Terri in Central Point, Or USA 10/31/2009
Best: Miky's Cantina Monterosso al Mare
Why: Few doors down from Miky's Restaurant in a basement. Same food, cheaper prices & funky decor.
Suzanne Chabon in Greensboro, NC USA 10/27/2009
Best: Trattoria da Billy Manarola, CT
Why: Not in book, but great food for less money than other CT eateries. High on the hillside with great views.
Worst: Trattoria Anita Florence
Why: Should have looked for lunch special. Dinner was expensive and one waiter was not very friendly.
Suzanne Chabon in Greensboro, NC USA 10/26/2009
Best: Pirate Bar, Vernazza, Cinque Terre
Why: Once again, the highlight of our trip was the Cinque Terra and one of the high points of that was the Pirate Bar. Great food, entertaining staff, great desserts. While waiting for a table, we started chatting with another couple and then ended up sharing a table and stories with them. We will continue to include a visit here on every trip to Italy.
PJ in Carlsbad, Ca USA 10/22/2009
Best: Taverna San Giuseppe
Why: Elegant candle lit setting, professional service, terrific hospitality, delicious food, souvenir jar of truffle-infused honey as a parting gift.
Worst: Trattoria Papei
Why: Outdoor seating is in a parking lot, and while other diners seemed to be enjoying themselves, we had the worst waiter of the entire trip here.
Kathy Healy in Manhattan Beach, CA USA 10/17/2009
Worst: Ristorante Delfino, Sorrento
Why: I have visited Delfino twice; once I ate there, and it was so-so food, and the place was empty. I just visited Sorrent for a second time and I forgot about the restaurant until we got there and it was empty again. An empty restaurant in Italy is not a good sign.
Sarah USA 10/12/2009
Best: Trattoria Za Za -Florence
Why: Great people watching spot, good food and wine and a great wait staff, didn't care how long you sat there and sipped and watched.
Worst: Restaurant di Gabriello- Rome
Why: Expensive, surly waiter, nondestcript food. To be fair, we were beginning to get tired and quite shell shocked by then, Rome is huge with a lot to see.
Diane in Salem, OR USA 10/11/2009
Best: La Vista in Varenna & Restaurante Belvedere in Monterossa
Why: The good was amazing--best sea bass ever--and the view of Lake Como is incomparable. Also, Edgy is such a wonderful presence in the dining room.
Lauren in Bloomington, MN USA 10/11/2009
Best: Trattoria da Lucia, Trastevere, Roma
Why: Absolutely delicious food, very nice atmosphere and lots of locals.
Marina in Washington, DC USA 10/05/2009
Best: Al Castello in Vernazza
Why: The service, the food, the views, but mostly it was the food. Fantastic dishes served up lovingly by the family who made them and overlooking priceless waterfront views.
Terri in San Francisco, CA USA 10/04/2009
Best: Tratoria La Palomba, Orvieto
Why: Good food, but also great embiance.
Ralph Perry in Cincinnati, Oh USA 09/30/2009
Best: L'Antica Tattoria dell 'Orso
Why: Arrived in the alley about 7:15 PM, after trying to make reservations by phone unsuccessfully. Just then a car pulled up along side of me and out stepped Ciro. He proceeded to unlock the door to enter. I then asked if we could make reservations for 7:30. He told us to come back in 15 to 20 minutes. We did and we were so, so happy we did. Upon arrival I mentioned Rick Steves was the reason we were there, and he reached out and gave me a big hug. "Rick-Rick Steves, what a wonderful man". He proceeded to tell me how he was there for lunch during the summer and paid for everything he ate. "Wonderful man and never wants anything for nothing". For those of us that question the validity of his ratings, this was definitely a pleasant sound to my ears. Ratings are not always paid for. As for the food???? Try and find any better. Gabriele came out and let us know what was on the menu, and prepared it deliciously for us. Would definitely have gone back if I had another night in Orvieto.
Jack & Sieni in Phoenix, Az USA 09/30/2009
Worst: Chat Qui Rit - Venice
Why: The food was OK - reasonable given the inflated prices everyone charges in Venice. I don't think, however, this should be one of your recommended restaurants because the management, while perhaps not outright dishonest, definitely takes advantage of tourists.
E.g., when we went, we looked at the posted menu, which listed prices for fish from 10-14 euros. So we picked out two fish dishes and when we went to pay at the end of the line, the cashier told us that one dish was 28 euros! We protested, but they said they had already prepared the dish (in the microwave). I guess we should have confirmed the price of each dish, but still, it felt sneaky.
Winston in San Jose, CA USA 09/27/2009
Best: Taverna San Giuseppe in Siena
Why: We loved the grotto atmosphere, and since it was a cool September evening, it was not stuffy at all. Everything was delicious, and we would have returned the next night had there been reservations. Reserve ahead!
Pamela Stutts in Virginia Beach, VA USA 09/27/2009
Best: almost all were very good and different and besides there were lots more than in the book to choose from
Why: Other than one meal all were very good.. wine , parm, bread, fruit, fish, wow, how can one go wrong!!
Worst: La Lanterna in Riomaggiore
Why: should be taken out of book. worst meal for service and food we had in Italy. Owners attitude was awful and rude. Food was really subpar.. I cannot say enough to discourage folks from going there. We were puzzled at how it was full most days and nights..
george scholz in las vegas, nm USA 09/27/2009
Best: Vernazza - U'tian Fish Shop
Why: On the main street there is a small restaurant with only two chairs and three stools. She has a small sign that says "Fish and Chips". She has the most amazing lemon anchovies and fried anchovies. Having only had American pizza anchovies previously, we had no idea how delicious fresh anchovies are. The fried anchovies are butterflied and quick fried to a crispy heavenly treat. The lemon anchovies are marinated in lemon and herbs and served cold. An amazing taste treat. The fish lady also runs the laundrymat on the lane behind her shop.
Mike, Luz, Kai in Blaine, WA USA 09/25/2009
Best: Trattoria da Emilia
Why: good food, location on the marina can't be beat!
Mike in LA, CA USA 09/18/2009
Best: Sora Margherita in Ghetto in Rome
Why: Wonderful warm welcoming. Our hostess took away our menus and just started bringing the food she wanted us to have. It was one great dish after another and very good value. Never would have found this place on our own.
Andrew Wheeler in Durham, NC USA 09/13/2009
Worst: Che Qua Rit Buffet in Venice
Why: The food was poorly prepared and overpriced. Staff very unhelpful. A big disappointment!!
Jim in Freedman, MA USA 09/07/2009
Best: Osteria Enoteca al Bric
Why: I just got back from Rome and Sicily as a single female traveler and wine lover. When you dine alone you are usually forced to have house wine which unlike you, I have not had great experiences with. However, here they were more than happy to give me a delicious full-bodied red wine by the glass. The bread before was different and exceptional - two pieces even had chocolate, the atmosphere is soft and romantic, the food is wonderfully prepared, and the bathrooms are great too!
Worst: Trattoria da Lucia - UPDATE
Why: It was closed which looked like either permanently or perhaps maybe a food violation - it didn't say "Per Ferie" but I was there the last two weeks of August so perhaps that was it. Osteria Ponte Sisto was closed for "Ferie"
Mary Catherine Donnelly in Brooklyn, NY USA 09/01/2009
Best: Trattoria Latte di Luna in Pienza
Why: The cinghale in a ragu over pasta melted in our mouths.
Karen in Reading, MA USA 08/30/2009
Best: osteria gusto (Rome), osteria Bancogiro, cicchetterie cantina da Mori - good wine, Antica ostaria Ruga Rialto (Venice)
Why: osteria gusto (Rome), osteria Bancogiro (Venice)-ggod food, but not cheap, especially in Venice cicchetterie cantina da Mori - good wine, cheap food. Antica ostaria Ruga Rialto (Venice) - very good seafood.
Worst: restaurants in Rome close to Colosseum
Why: You could it there only simple pizza. Expensive and bad.
Natasha Novitskaia-Adams in Greenwich, CT USA 08/29/2009
Best: Pizzeria la Perla, Venice
Why: Great variety of excellent pizzas and salads. Amazing customer service. We went there in early July and we accidentally left behind a small item (a bib clip for our daughter). We stopped by the next day, but they hadn't seen it. A month later, we were back in Venice with a different set of friends, and we went to Pizzeria la Perla for dinner. After she took our orders, the waitress went somewhere and came back with the bib clip we had left there 4 weeks earlier! I have no idea how she remembered us or why she even thought to keep this little thing, but she made some fans for life.
Meredith USA 08/12/2009
Best: Pizzeria di Michele, Naples
Why: Hands down, this is the mecca of pizza! There's a good reason the locals line up here. Great, cheap pizza. If there's a lineup outside, go in and find the guy handing out numbers. Don't be discouraged. They turn tables over really fast!
Worst: The Foreigner's Club, Sorrento
Why: This is one of those places that you go to for the view, which is stunning, but not the food. Canned asparagus in Italy in the summer? You've got to be kidding me. My daughter's pasta was passable.
Laura in Kirkland, Wa USA 08/04/2009
Best: Miky, Monterosso
Why: Fabulous food,service and location: our gastronomic highlight of the trip. Can still taste the delicious pasta covered with bread!!!
Worst: Ristorante al Castello and Gambero Rosso
Why: Quality of food not up to our expectations from the book and compared to the rest of the food we enjoyed in the Cinque Terra. Also way overpriced!!
Sazia Samad in London, UK 07/27/2009
Worst: Verde Mare on Via Capo
Why: The food was good, but the service was lousy. I found out that they ignore foreigners and favor locals. We had to beg four or five different waiters for food, my husband gave up on coffee and dessert. We discussed getting up and walking out to see if they would realize we hadn't paid because that might be the only way to get their attention. Took pleading to get our bill at the end.
Iris Posin in Deerfield Beach, FL USA 07/19/2009
Best: Pisa: Paninoteca il Canguro - for humor
Why: He was so funny. I ordered the primavera - there weren't any in his sandwich case. He sighed and asked me if I was using "the book" I said yes, he said he makes many other very good sandwiches and I should try one of them. I answered that I will order another type next time I visit. My other family members ordered other items which seemed to appeased him :-)
Christine Elias in Vancouver, Wa USA 07/17/2009
Worst: Trattoria 13 Gobi
Why: This is the ONLY restaurant in our 16 day trip that disappointed. All your other recommendations were wonderful. This restaurant had poor service;especially a waiter named "Urban".It was filled with your readers by the way (we ate there the evening of July 3,2009). Urban was a class "A" butthole. He was rude and cndescending in a way we've never experienced in Italy. The food was not very good either. They forgot to give us EVOO with our bread and when we asked (very politely AND in Italian) Urban got all snotty with us..Anyway there are palenty of nice trattorias in Florence. I'd drop this place.
Mike Exner in Germantown, TN USA 07/14/2009
Best: The terrace at the hotel Milano, Varenna
Why: An absolutely amazing view out over the lake, and delicious food, served nicely.
Paula Parker in Atlanta, GA USA 07/11/2009
Best: Trattoria Da Remigio, Venice; Il Latini, Florence, Buca Lapi, Florence Late di Luna, Pienza, Miky, Monterosso
Why: Felt we were part of the Italian scene and had wonderful service and food. Buca Lapi is expensive but worth the splurge. Had more fun at Il Latini. Latte di Luna is a bargain but hard to get a reservation.
Jeanette Finlon in Seattle, WA USA 07/09/2009
Best: Trattoria Da Remigio, Venice; Il Latini, Florence, Buca Lapi, Florence Late di Luna, Pienza, Miky, Monterosso
Why: Felt we were part of the Italian scene and had wonderful service and food. Buca Lapi is expensive but worth the splurge. Had more fun at Il Latini. Latte di Luna is a bargain but hard to get a reservation.
Jeanette Finlon in Seattle, WA USA 07/09/2009
Worst: Tratoria Za Za, Florence
Why: The food was bland and the service was extremely slow. Slowest service and worst food we had during two weeks in Europe.
Barry Blodgett in Cary, IL USA 07/07/2009
Best: Florence...$12 three course meal, forgot the name...
Why: Full of locals, excellent atmosphere and delicious food, all cheap! Great service too.
Michaela Baglietto in Medford, OR USA 07/05/2009
Best: The Foreigners' Club in Sorrento
Why: Unparalleled view of Bay of Naples, excellent food at reasonable prices, chance to meet many new people (and not just old fogeys feeling frisky!).
Deborah in North Port, FL USA 06/27/2009
Best: Restaurante Belvedere in Monterosso
Why: Had the house specialty. What an experience
Worst: Trattoria Nona in Venice
Why: Very mediocre food after what we had been getting.
Mary in Tucson, AZ USA 06/22/2009
Best: Trattoria da Olindo
Why: Best meal we had in Rome. Far removed from more touristy areas in Rome but not actually that far. Family run and the food is great. Homecooked and delicious. The menu is in Italian and English.
Worst: Dining on Campo de' Fiori
Why: Although the atmosphere is fun, I wouldn't recommend eating there. The food is not authentic and for that matter not very good, and it just feels really touristy. I think that there are other places in Rome such as Travestere where you can get better food and a better atmosphere.
Zoe in Port Washington, NY USA 06/01/2009
Best: Enoteca Cangrande in Verona
Why: Never had a 4 hour dinner anywhere in my life. These people made it seem effortless, worthwhile as if there was no other way to eat. The food was an amazing intro to Italy
Duane Henderson in Chico, CA USA 05/31/2009
Best:
Why: The hotel in Milan recommend a place to eat across the street and we enjoyed the food and staff so much we had dinner there every night. For our lunches we just stopped some place that looked good when we were hungry. So fun. We did the same in Rome for lunches. tried to go onto a side street both times to find more local places. We used the cafe at the hotel in Rome for dinner. Very good service and food. We like to go to bed early, by 9, so wanted to eat close to our hotels. This next trip we are going to be more "Italian" and eat a little later, stay up a little later and take an afternoon nap.
Janice Humphrey in Colorado Springs, CO USA 05/26/2009
Worst: Ristorante di Bruno in Milan
Why: Food was ok. Dining outside is VERY noisy. The main issue though was the fact that it seemed their English skills left them when we tried to point out a 20 euro mistake in the bill. The bill itself was just a scrap of paper with a list of numbers!
Frank Spence in Wilmington, de USA 05/25/2009
Best: Restaurants in Varenna, Lake Como - Ristorante del Sole and Ristorante Montecodeno
Why: Both are good restaurants. Locals seems to eat at Ristorante del Sole and price are reasonable. Rick Steves' special is still offered at Ristorante Montecoden for Euro 26 as of May 2009. All four of us ordered the specials and three out of four likes the food.
Worst: Trattoria Milanese in Milan, Italy
Why: We used the Italy 2007 guide for restaurants. The restaurant was closed and might have been moved to the Canel area.
UN and friends in los angeles, ca USA 05/24/2009
Best: Obika in the La Rinascente Dept Store & Da Rita e Antonio
Why: Obika was one of the very few restaurants open before 7:30pm so was great when we first arrived in Milan and had not adjusted to eating early... great mozzarella & antipasto. The next night, Da Rita e Antonio was worth while waiting for... best ossobuco & pizza!!!
Meredith Kupferman in Rancho Murieta, CA USA 05/16/2009
Best: Miky's in Monterosso
Why: Service is exceptional. We had a reservation and we welcomed to our table immediately. We wanted to order the fresh fish of the day but didn't know how to distinguish between the three choices so Sara put the three different raw/whole fish on a platter and wheeled it out to our table to better explain to us! Our waiter was amazingly attentive and had such flair in his presentation of food. It was truly a delight to eat there....worth EVERY Euro. :-)
Worst: Ciak in Monterosso
Why: We got to this restaurant, told the waiter we needed a table for 4. We were then told to wait for 10 minutes. During this time, two tables for 4 opened up and were given away to other people even though we were waiting (hovering actually) right there. My boyfriend even reminded them a couple of times and they were very rude and brushed him off even though he was extremely polite. I thought they were very unwelcoming.
Gina in Los Angeles, CA USA 05/11/2009
Worst: La Bucaccia, Cortona
Why: This was the antithesis of a Rick Steve's restaurant. it was very expensive and very touristy. The owner was obnoxious, if not down right rude. He pretended not to know about the book, but was quick to correct us about the free appetizer -- which was a measly thin slice of salami (like you'd get at the Piggly Wiggly deli counter). He used his daughter as an extension of his showmanship. It was all too contrived and phony. The meal was mediocre at best. Not good food, very high price, and over the top tourist pandering. It was the worst meal I've ever had in Italy.
Joseph Mollo in Moorestown, NJ USA 05/09/2009
Worst: Trattoria al Trebbio, Florence
Why: Poor service. Also, the restaurant added a 2.50 euro per person fee to the bill as a "cover charge". We ate inside and were not informed of this fee up front. The waiter said that the fee was for the table setting, mats, etc. but I suspect that it was just another "tourist tax".
ben caputo in arlington heights, il USA 04/30/2009
Best: Pirata della Cinque Terre & Romanica Pucci
Why: The pastry at Pirata in Vernazza were to die for! The brother/owners of the restaurant serve great food and are a crack-up. Romantica Pucci had the best food overall
Worst: Restaurant Lanterna in Rio Maggiore
Why: This is the only food in Italy I didn't like! I didn't understand that Crawdads are really what scampi is either. Yuck! Really expensive yuck! Other dishes ordered by other patrons looked much better.
Jeanette Rollinger in Visalia, CA USA 04/27/2009
Best: Osteria da Nerone (Rome)
Why: Great service & great food (ate there twice). Also had a wonderful dinner at Pirata delle Cinque Terre with the delightful Canoli twins as our hosts. Others raved about the breakfast there too.
Brad Franklin in Portland, Or USA 04/22/2009
Best: Gelatoria just to the left of Orvieto's duomo
Why: Best chocolate gelato we had the whole trip, homemade too. It was even better than Giolitti in Rome
Erica Blankenbehler in San Jose, CA USA 04/19/2009
Best: Il Gabriello in Rome
Why: The food was fabulous. Everything from the bread to the house wine to the entrees to the desserts. Perfect we went back a second time for our last night in Rome. The service was wonderful as well.
Ellen in Anaheim, ca USA 04/11/2009
Best: Trattoria Gianni, Vernazza
Why: Beautiful setting, fantastic food, pleasant service
Pat Millar in Dartmouth, NS Canada 04/08/2009
Best: Trattoria La Torre in Siena
Why: Excellent food, fun atmosphere, great service. Wonderful real italian experience. Very reasonably priced
Janice Cain in Pleasanton, CA USA 04/02/2009
Best: Le Coppelle Taverna in Rome near Pantheon
Why: The food was inexpensive, but fantastic! The service was also incredible - the owner went out of his way to make our meal one to remember. Lots of locals eat here, so it has a fun atmosphere.
Harold in Saskatchewan, Canada 04/02/2009
Best: Vecchia Varenna
Why: Great food, right on the waterfront with view of the mountains and lake!
Gale in Melbourne Beach, FL USA 03/29/2009
Best: Alfredo's in Rome
Why: Outstanding service, wine and of course the "original Fettucini Alfredo! (not sure this was a recommended one?)
Patti Koupal in Rapid City, SD USA 03/19/2009
Best: Pizzeria Du de Cope, Verona
Why: We some difficulty finding it and had to ask a local for directions. I am so glad we did! It was the best pizza I've had in Italy (so far)! We went back for another meal and will continue to return. Our waiter was great too. He made recommendations for pizza, explaining the menu as we needed. He also recommended a great regional beer. If you are visiting Verona, I highly recommend Pizzeria Du de Cope. Go early though, as it fills up fast (especially on Saturday nights) and you may have to wait for a table.
Samantha in Vicenza, Italy 02/24/2009
Best: Trattoria da Giorgio
Why: The description of this restaurant was spot on. We ate dinner there in Florence and the meal was 12 euros which came with first dish, secondi, and an appetizer. Wine also came with the meal. The food was delicious and the service was very good. This isn't the kind of place that attracts tourists for money; it really deserves more than a worthy mention!!
Worst: La Sagrestia-via Guicciardini, 27/R (off of the Ponte Vecchio)
Why: This was a restaurant we went to in Florence. The place attracts tourists with a lunch of either salad or pizza costing 5 euros. Yet, what they don't tell you is that there is a 2 Euro service charge per person. We should've known something was wrong when the group ready to depart the restaurant complained to the manager that one of the people who did not eat was still charged the 2Euro service charge. Our waiter was rude, and very rushed and was impatient with most of the people in the restaurant. When we tried to get the service charged reduced because our waiter was rude, the manager simply walked away and didn't respond. When my friends and I decided to warn incoming customers (two gentleman from the US), not to come in the restaurant, the manager immediately began hurling racists comments to us in Italian (I know they were racist comments b/c I understand the language). Additionally, he gestured to us by putting his finger in his mouth (I won't go into what this suggests). He was extremely irate and very loud, at the sight of this the other customers immediately left the restaurant. I have no personal grudge towards this management, but I think that visitors (particularly those not from Italy) need to be aware of this type of establishment and need to avoid it because it was not very professional for the manager to react in this way.
Vivian in Paramus, NJ USA 02/16/2009
Best: Il Gabrielle in Rome
Why: Wonderful experience. Great food. Great Host making us feel welcome.
Pat Oliver in Palos Park, IL USA 01/28/2009
Best: Acauacotta, Florence
Why: A small restaurant on a small street with a friendly staff and very creative and well prepared meal for a reasonable price. My wife had Pheasant ravioli with truffle sauce and I had an Artichoke crepe. Both were around 12 Euro. It was definitely one of the very best meals we had in Italy.
Scott in Wainess, CA USA 01/21/2009